Comparison
Obsidian MCP vs. a hosted notes workspace
Local vault charm — and its rough edges
Obsidian is a beloved local-first markdown editor, and there are several community MCP servers (like mcp-obsidian) that let Claude read and write to a vault. If you already live in Obsidian, that's a great setup. But it's also a real amount of plumbing.
What Obsidian + MCP actually requires
- An Obsidian vault on disk.
- The Local REST API community plugin, enabled and running.
- A community MCP server (npm or Docker), pointed at the vault.
- Claude Desktop or Claude Code configured to talk to that MCP server.
- The machine has to be on for the assistant to reach anything.
And to see the same notes on your phone or a second laptop, you need Obsidian Sync (paid) or a manual sync (git, iCloud, Syncthing) plus an MCP server running somewhere both can reach.
Side-by-side
| Obsidian + MCP | Muninn | |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | Vault + plugin + local MCP server | Sign in, copy MCP URL |
| Cross-device | Obsidian Sync or DIY sync | Automatic |
| Availability | Only when your machine is on | Always on |
| Works in ChatGPT / Codex | Whatever your MCP server exposes | Yes — remote MCP |
| Editing UI | Obsidian (excellent) | Muninn web editor |
| Best for | Existing Obsidian users on one machine | New setups, multi-device, cross-assistant |
When Obsidian MCP wins
- You already have a beloved vault and don't want to move it.
- You want a rich local editor with plugins and graph view.
- You're comfortable maintaining a small local server stack.
When Muninn wins
- You want AI memory without installing anything.
- You want it available from your phone and second laptop.
- You want the same store working in ChatGPT and Codex too.
- You don't want a machine-must-be-on constraint.
Can I have both?
Yes — configure Claude with both MCP servers. Muninn for cross-device memory, Obsidian for local vault notes. Claude will pick whichever has what it needs.
Related reading
Skip the plumbing — try Muninn.